Send a story
Courts

High Court dismisses summary judgment bid over £416,499 rail lift dispute

Mr Justice Moody refused a summary judgment application brought by Serapid against Octavius Infrastructure on 22 October 2026, Keystone Law said on its website on 6 November 2026.

Automated report. This article was drafted with AI assistance from the sources listed below, without a human writing step. Law Week labels every article produced this way. A person is answerable for it: if something here is wrong, write to editor@law-week.com and we will correct it on the page and say what changed.

Lede

Mr Justice Moody dismissed an application for summary judgment brought by lift manufacturer Serapid, which had sought to enforce a £416,499 adjudication award against Octavius Infrastructure, on 22 October 2026. According to Keystone Law, the firm represented Octavius throughout the High Court proceedings, which concerned the attempted enforcement of the award.

Key points

  • The dispute concerned whether Octavius and Serapid had entered into a binding subcontract for the manufacture and installation of lifts on a Network Rail step-free access project at Chalkwell Station in Essex.
  • Serapid had obtained a £416,499 adjudication award, excluding VAT, but Octavius challenged enforcement on the grounds that no subcontract existed and disputed the adjudicator’s jurisdiction.
  • Mr Justice Moody found that Octavius had a real prospect of establishing that no binding subcontract had been formed.
  • Keystone Law said its team was led by Construction Partner Louise Garcia, working alongside Construction Consultant Solicitor Neave Maguire, a paralegal and a legal assistant.
  • The firm said Peter Brogden, of Keating Chambers, represented the team in court.

Contract formation issue

According to Keystone Law, the judgment raises a point relevant to the construction and infrastructure sectors: beginning work while terms remain under negotiation does not, by itself, establish that a binding contract has been agreed.

Louise Garcia, Construction Partner at Keystone Law, said: “This judgment provides an important reminder for contractors and suppliers about the need for clarity when negotiating and performing construction contracts. The fact that work has commenced does not necessarily mean that a binding contract has been formed, particularly where important contractual and commercial matters remain under negotiation.”

Ms Garcia also said: “It also underlines the significance of jurisdiction in adjudication proceedings. Where there is a genuine dispute about whether the underlying contract exists, that issue can have a fundamental bearing on whether an adjudicator’s decision can be summarily enforced.”

Representation

Keystone Law said the matter was handled by Ms Garcia together with Neave Maguire, Lucy Ramsey and Lila Priechenfried, with Peter Brogden of Keating Chambers appearing as counsel.

Sources